2009 Capital Crusader Softball Schedule & Results (20-16, 8-10 OAC)
| Day | Date | Opponent | Location | Time/Result |
| FEBRUARY | | | | |
| Mon. | 23 | vs. Hanover | Clermont, Fla. | W, 6-0 |
| Mon. | 23 | vs. Davenport | Clermont, Fla. | W, 5-4 (8 inn.) |
| Tue. | 24 | vs. Alma | Clermont, Fla. | W, 3-1 |
| Tue. | 24 | vs. Concordia-Moorehead | Clermont, Fla. | L, 1-3 |
| Thu. | 26 | vs. Grove City (DH) | Clermont, Fla. | W, 2-1 (Gm 1) |
| | | | | L, 3-6 (Gm 2) |
| Fri. | 27 | vs. Lake Superior State | Clermont, Fla. | W, 6-2 (9 inn.) |
| Fri. | 27 | vs. #16 Rochester | Clermont, Fla. | L, 0-3 |
| MARCH | | | | |
| Sun. | 1 | vs. Alma | Clermont, Fla. | L, 3-6 |
| Sun. | 1 | vs. Clark | Clermont, Fla. | W, 8-3 |
| | | | | |
| Fri-Sat. | 20-21 | at Salisbury Invitational | Salisbury, Md. | |
| Fri. | 20 | vs. SUNY Geneseo | Salisbury, Md. | W, 3-1 |
| Fri. | 20 | vs. College of New Jersey | Salisbury, Md. | W, 3-2 |
| Sat. | 21 | vs. SUNY Plattsburgh | Salisbury, Md. | W, 2-0 |
| Sat. | 21 | vs. #23 Ithaca | Salisbury, Md. | L, 1-3 |
| | | | | |
| TUE. | 24 | TRANSYLVANIA (DH) | HOME | W, 2-0 (Gm 1) |
| | | | | L, 6-11 (Gm 2) |
| THU. | 26 | THOMAS MORE (DH) | HOME | PPD. to 4/8 |
| Sat. | 28 | at Wilmington (OAC) (DH) | Wilmington, Ohio | PPD. to 3/30 |
| SUN. | 29 | BETHANY (DH) | HOME | PPD. to 4/23 |
| Mon. | 30 | at Wilmington (OAC) (DH) | Wilmington, Ohio | W, 6-1 (Gm 1) |
| | | | | W, 7-3 (Gm 2) |
| APRIL | | | | |
| WED. | 1 | MUSKINGUM (OAC) (DH) | HOME | L, 3-7 (Gm 1) |
| | | | | L, 0-6 (Gm 2) |
| SAT. | 4 | BALDWIN-WALLACE (OAC) (DH) | HOME | L, 2-3 (Gm 1) |
| | | | | L, 0-5 (Gm 2) |
| Tue. | 7 | at Mount Union (OAC) (DH) | Alliance, Ohio | PPD. TO 4/8 |
| Wed. | 8 | at Mount Union (OAC) (DH) | Alliance, Ohio | W, 5-3 (Gm 1) |
| | | | | W, 4-3 (Gm 2) |
| WED. | 8 | THOMAS MORE (DH) | HOME | PPD. TO 4/20 |
| FRI. | 10 | HEIDELBERG (OAC) (DH) | HOME | PPD. TO 4/11 |
| SAT. | 11 | HEIDELBERG (OAC) (DH) | HOME | W, 7-0 (Gm 1) |
| | | | | W, 6-2 (Gm 2) |
| Mon. | 13 | at Mount St. Joseph (DH) | Cincinnati, Ohio | PPD. TO 4/16 |
| Wed. | 15 | at John Carroll (OAC) (DH) | University Heights, Ohio | PPD. TO 4/17 |
| Thu. | 16 | at Mount St. Joseph (DH) | Cincinnati, Ohio | W, 2-1 (F/8 inn.) (Gm 1) |
| | | | | W, 8-2 (Gm 2) |
| Fri. | 17 | at John Carroll (OAC) (DH) | University Heights, Ohio | L, 0-3 (Gm 1) |
| | | | | L, 0-2 (Gm 2) |
| SAT. | 18 | #12 OHIO NORTHERN (OAC) (DH) | HOME | L, 4-8 (Gm 1) |
| | | | | L, 2-5 (Gm 2) |
| MON. | 20 | THOMAS MORE (DH) | HOME | CANCELLED |
| TUE. | 21 | MARIETTA (OAC) (DH) | HOME | PPD. TO 4/23 |
| THU. | 23 | MARIETTA (OAC) (DH) | HOME | W, 3-2 (Gm 1) |
| | | | | L, 2-6 (Gm 2) |
| THU. | 23 | BETHANY (DH) | HOME | CANCELLED |
| Sat. | 25 | at Otterbein (OAC) (DH) | Westerville, Ohio | W, 4-3 (Gm 1) |
| | | | | L, 3-5 (Gm 2) |